Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (Episode 5) – Rain of Sorrows

Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Title

Edward struggles to come to terms with what happened to Nina and how there was nothing he could do to help her. He starts to question the path he’s taken, but then a mysterious man shows up and he’s not the questioning type!

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (Episode 5) – Rain of Sorrows

What happened?

Edward had a nightmare in which he saw his mother and Nina. Unable to help them has become a tiresome burden on his soul. All he can do is see what will happen to Shou Tucker and how will the military handle Nina. When he goes to get some answers, he bumps into Riza Hawkeye who is on her way to Tucker’s house. She informs him that Shou and Nina were both murdered.

Riza meets with Roy Mustang at the scene of the crime. Alex Louis Armstrong and Maes Hughes are already there discussing the situation. They bring Roy and Riza up to speed and implore Roy to lay low as this murderer is targeting State Alchemists. That’s when Roy remembers that Edward is still in the city.

Edward and Alphonse, however, are blissfully unaware of what dangers they face until a mysterious scarred man approaches and attacks Edward. Alphonse pulls him to safety at the last second and they try to run. The attacker is quick and able to destroy things with his touch, not unlike an alchemist.

He breaks up Alphonse’s suit of armour and then Edward’s arm. However, they managed to buy enough time for the military to catch up. Roy goes to challenge the murderer, but Riza saves him at the last second. It’s raining and he’s basically useless when it rains. Luckily, Alex Louis Armstrong is on hand to fight. They have the murderer surrounded and have discovered that he is an Ishavaly. However, he escapes into the sewers.

Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Episode 5 Scar detroys Alphonse

What did you think?

I thought this was a great episode. I’m glad that they didn’t just move on from the Shou Tucker incident and gave Edward some time to process what had happened and how it impacted him. He seemed like he was ready to quit on numerous occasions, the last time when he seemed resigned to die at the hands of Scar. Can I just say that I understand why they would call him Scar between themselves, but when addressing him, it seemed a bit bizarre!

Alex Louis Armstrong continues to be a great source of entertainment while Roy is essentially a hothead with nothing to back it up so far. I’m sure he’s powerful, but the rain causing him issues is a fairly big weakness. Especially as it seems to rain fairly often there, at least from what we’ve seen so far. There was a lot of progression with the Ishval side of things, which had only been hinted at before now. We just need to see what Lust, Gluttony, and Envy are up to… and where the other four deadly sins are!

Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Episode 5 Alex Louis Armstrong

What have you learnt?

For a story to have a satisfying high point, it must first go low. These last couple of episodes have shown Edward and Alphonse on a tragic descent. It’s classic storytelling and it works. I get the sense that there will be a lot of highs and lows in this season given how long it is and each time, they will be bigger and more shocking.

The other main thing I’m wondering is whether Edward and Alphonse have found themselves on the right side. You’ve got to worry about a military organisation where the leader’s title is fuhrer… I feel like it will probably end up being a little less clear cut than it seems, but I hope there’s lots of questioning the status quo which will lead to startling discoveries. Also, curious about what Lust, Gluttony, and Envy are since they don’t seem to consider themselves humans! Lots of questions is always the sign of a good show!

Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Episode 5 Alphonse and Edward survived

Other posts in the series

You might also like…

Mushoku Tensei Jobless Reincarnation Episode 8 Rudeus tries his new staff
Fire Force Episode 1 Special Fire Force

Lynn Sheridan The Otaku Author Header


  1. It’s pretty interesting reading this because I’ve not seen Brotherhood yet but I did see the original FMA years ago and did find it rather odd how abruptly the Nina situation was kind of moved ahead from. That episode is critical because it just goes to such abject depths of darkness you cannot foresee. Your article made me want to go back and watch FMAB now. Thanks for that. Very well written! Oh and I love Armstrong too!

    • Thanks. I haven’t seen the original either so it’s all new to me, other than the various things that have spread online. It was a really dark moment and needed some time to reflect, especially for Edward who was probably the driving force behind their attempt to resurrect their mother. Thanks for reading and Armstrong is awesome.

What did you think?